Early breast cancer screening may help some: study
A patient receives a screening mammogram (D. Clarke Evans/NBAE via Getty Images)
NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - Starting breast cancer screening as early as age 25 may help women who carry a genetic mutation linked to a higher risk of cancer live longer, suggests a new study.
"Results indicate that breast cancer deaths will decrease because of screening," study co-author Dr. Janie Lee, who specializes in breast imaging at Massachusetts General Hospital, said by email.
The study, reported in the journal Cancer, found that compared to no screening at all, annual screening starting at age 25 extended life by 1.3 to 1.8 years. Screening with a breast MRI every six months extended life by 1.5 to 1.7 years.
The tests were not perfect. Over the course of their lives, women with BRCA1 who began having mammograms at the age of 25 would have two false positives -- a finding that doesn't turn out to be cancer. Those women with BRCA1 who had an annual mammogram and breast MRI would have four false positives.
For BRCA2 carriers, the corresponding numbers of false positives were three and eight.
The authors based their findings on a computer model that may not translate into real life, noted Dr. Carol Fabian, who specializes in breast cancer research at the University of Kansas and was not part of the study.
"This is a model so they are applying things that have been learned in other studies," Fabian told Reuters Health.
In women 40 years or younger with breast cancer, about 1 in 10 are likely to have a BRCA mutation, according to the National Cancer Institute.
The United States Preventive Services Task Force, a government-funded agency, recommends breast cancer screening for all women beginning at age 50. BRCA carriers are encouraged to start screening at a young age by groups such as the American Cancer Society, which recommends screening at age 30, five years later than when the study suggests.
"Starting at 25 years may have a slight benefit, but for most women 30 is good too," said Dr. Debbie Saslow, director of breast and gynecologic cancer for the American Cancer Society.
"For women who have a BRCA mutation in their family and have family members who were diagnosed younger than age 40, they should consider screening at age 25," she said.
Still, annual screenings can add up to high costs. MRIs can cost more than $1,000, while mammograms cost less than $200. Saslow said that insurance companies typically cover women considered high-risk.
Another concern with screening is repeated radiation exposure, especially among those at increased risk of breast cancer.
When researchers factored in radiation risk, they found fewer than 5 out of 100 women who were BRCA carriers were diagnosed with breast cancer due to exposure to radiation.
"The risk of getting breast cancer from radiation is small compared to the risk of dying from breast cancer if you don't get screening," Fabian said. "It's an acceptable tradeoff."
Source: http://bit.ly/pN50Qt Cancer, September 20, 2011.
(Corrects quote in fifth-from-last paragraph, posted Oct 5, 2011)