By Charles McNulty, Los Angeles Times Theater Critic
1:00 PM EDT, October 11, 2013
If you were to sum up the history of the American musical, the tale would go something like this: Over time, patchwork entertainments featuring loosely strung together musical numbers became integrated by book writers, the best of whom looked to composers as fellow authors. A golden age gleamed during the postwar boom, when popular radio and Broadway were still in sync. The invasion of the Beatles would change all that, but the whole glorious enterprise would really come undone by a decadent commercialism that would leave Broadway at the turn of the millennium awash in jukebox nostalgia and theme park kitsch.
The historical record is, of course, infinitely more various, as Ethan Mordden never lets us forget in his latest chronicle of the American musical, "Anything Goes: A History of American Musical Theatre." For every pattern that can be discerned, there's an unforgettable exception, a show insouciantly bucking prevailing trends. This makes the history inherently challenging to write, and Mordden, an extraordinarily knowledgeable guide (you can imagine him buried in his apartment under an avalanche of playbills and cast albums), can't help disrupting categories the moment he establishes them.
His book is divided into four eras: The first concentrates on the European prehistory, the second on the American pond out of which Jerome Kern crawled, the third on the glory days that stretched from Oscar Hammerstein to Stephen Sondheim, and the fourth on the deliquescence and decline that are our unenviable inheritance.
This chronology suggests an orderly evolutionary march, but Mordden's title indicates his awareness that musicals survive by their wits. They exist to please a fickle audience, and no matter how much artists may wish to push the envelope creatively, staying open for business is a show's primary concern.
The arts clearly aren't progressive in any continuous sense, for if they were, how would you explain Andrew Lloyd Webber, pop opera's vintage sentimentalist, succeeding Stephen Sondheim, who made his name perfecting the radical experiment taken up by Rodgers & Hammerstein in "Allegro"?
"Anything Goes" corrects many false assumptions, including perhaps the most common, that the American musical is a purely homegrown invention. It's true that this wide-ranging category discovered its potential in the polyglot churn of New York's immigrant communities, who frenetically chased the American dream down glittering showbiz lanes. But the operettas of the British duo Gilbert & Sullivan and the Continental offerings of Jacques Offenbach were formatively influential. Mordden begins by persuasively arguing that the first musical was — steady, patriots — "The Beggar's Opera," produced in London in 1728.
The Irish-born, German-raised American composer Victor Herbert, a figure usually given cursory treatment, is credited here with being the D.W. Griffith of the American musical. In addition to his role as "grammarian, innovator and debate-club coach," he is said to have "reshaped the very structure of the American song, shortening the verse and lengthening the chorus till his heirs, from Irving Berlin and Jerome Kern to Rodgers and Hart and the Gershwins, had a more dramatically protean format to work with."
Naturally, it's those latter names that will cause musical aficionados to prick up their ears. Mordden, who has already written a series of books examining the Broadway musical decade by decade, reviews this familiar ground with a lighter touch than that of Larry Stempel, whose "Showtime: A History of the Broadway Musical Theater" offers a more rigorously synthesized history.
More journalistic than academic, "Anything Goes" has a relaxed spryness. ("Oklahoma!" in Mordden memorable formulation, "is a musical comedy undergoing psychoanalysis.") It's the work of an expert who is also an unabashed fan, an inveterate theatergoer who can deconstruct a score and reel off sparking backstage anecdotes all in the same paragraph. (The book includes a strikingly candid discography that brings out both sides of Mordden's character, which may have some of you recalling the fussy fanaticism of Man in Chair from "The Drowsy Chaperone.)
One section stands out: The chapter titled "The Rodgers and Hammerstein Handbook" magnificently distills what made this composer-lyricist/book-writer team so groundbreaking — chiefly, the central importance they placed on "character traction" in the score and the way they proved to everyone that the musical could pursue tragic or "romantically inconclusive" stories without sacrificing broad audience appeal.
There's a Sondheim handbook as well, but it's a bit of a ruse, focused mostly on dispelling the false notions that have accumulated around his work, humorously encapsulated in a single sentence: "If Sondheim had written 'Oklahoma!', the farmer and the cowman would still be fighting."
"Anything Goes" reads too much like an almanac in its final chapters. Mordden singles out shows he believes are significant for advancing a development in the musical's history (say, the rise of the director-choreographer) or enshrining a trend (such as the modern day "Compassion Musical," in which sympathy is generated for largely unsympathetic characters). But the inventory begins to crowd out insight.
Mordden's ardor sometimes dulls his critical faculties. He thinks "Titanic" got a bad rap from critics who wanted to make sinking ship jokes, can see only one flaw in the widely derided "Women on the Verge of a Nervous Breakdown" musical adaptation and heaps undue praise on "Wicked" for its dramatic substance and "melodious" score. But occasional overzealousness is a pardonable offense from an author who never runs out of interesting things to say about his lifelong passion.
Anything Goes: A History of American Musical Theatre
Oxford: 346 pp., $29.95
Copyright © 2016, Los Angeles Times